braids · protective styles
Box Braids vs. Knotless Braids: HowThey Compare
Box braids vs. knotless braids compared by tension, install time, weight, how long they last, and cost, with how to look after your edges and scalp.
Hairover Team
Box braids start with a small knot at the base, which secures the extension. Knotless braids begin with your own hair and gradually feed extension hair in, so there is no knot. Knotless braids usually feel lighter and pull less on the scalp, but they take longer and often cost more. Box braids install faster and can hold firmly at the root.
Side by side
| Box braids | Knotless braids | |
|---|---|---|
| Start of each braid | Small knot | Your own hair, no knot |
| Tension at first | More | Less |
| Install time | Shorter | Longer |
| Weight at the root | More | Less |
| Lies flat | Less at the root | Yes |
| Cost | Often less | Often more |
Install times and prices depend heavily on your hair, the braid size and length, and the braider.
When to choose each
Choose knotless if you have a sensitive scalp or fine edges, or you want to wear your braids in an updo soon after install. They tend to feel comfortable sooner.
Choose box braids if you want a faster install, or you want extra security at the root for fine or slippery hair. An experienced braider can advise you on this.
Protect your edges either way
Tension is the main risk with any braid. Repeated pulling on the hairline can cause traction alopecia, which can become permanent if it continues.
- Speak up if a braid hurts during the install. Pain, bumps, or headaches are not normal.
- Do not keep heavy styles in for too long.
- Avoid big, heavy braids around the hairline.
- Give your hair and scalp a break between styles.
- See a dermatologist if your edges start thinning.
Caring for braids
Keep your scalp clean with a diluted shampoo, and dry your braids thoroughly. Sleep in a satin scarf or bonnet to reduce friction. A light, non-greasy scalp product can help with dryness. When you take them down, be patient and detangle gently, since shed hair builds up over the weeks.
Things to ask your braider
- How will you protect my edges?
- What size and length would you recommend for my hair’s strength?
- How long should I keep them in?
- Do I need to prep my hair, or will you wash it?
Related guides
- Starter Locs: Methods, Stages, and What to Expect
- How to Braid Hair: A Beginner’s Guide to the Basic Braid
Thinking beyond braids
If you are weighing up cuts for your natural hair as well, our hair type chart and guide to 4C hair are helpful places to start. Hairover also lets you upload a clear photo, get a hair analysis, and try hairstyles on your own face in Style Studio.
FAQ
Are knotless braids better for your edges?
They usually put less tension on the scalp, since they do not start with a knot. They can still cause damage if they are installed too tightly or kept in too long.
How long do braids last?
Commonly around four to eight weeks, depending on your hair, how well you care for them, and the size of the braids. Ask your braider what they recommend for your hair.
Which takes longer to install?
Knotless braids usually take longer, since hair is fed in gradually. As a result, they often cost more, though the price varies widely by area and braid size.
